Mailing List
Sign up for updates in your city.
Events Calendar
Search for content |
A CORN-FED CONGRESSMAN SLAMS ORGANICS
Submitted by KAT on Thu, 10/18/2007 - 5:32pm.
Take Collin Peterson, the Minnesota Democrat who’s chairman of the House of Representatives agricultural committee. This week, Peterson pooh-poohed the notion that the farm bill should offer more support for organic farmers, telling the Financial Times that organic farming’s share of the market is doing just fine and dandy without any assistance: "It is growing, and it has nothing to do with the government, and that is good…for whatever reason, people are willing to pay two or three times as much for something that says 'organic' or 'local'. Far be it from me to understand what that's about, but that's reality. And if people are dumb enough to pay that much then hallelujah."
Well, he’s only head of the ag committee, and he did grow up on a farm, so it’s not unreasonable to think that Peterson might be conversant with the issues that compel so many consumers to seek out—and pay more for—organic and local foods. Yet Peterson pretends to be puzzled by the boom in organic food sales, and can only conclude that those of us who frequent the farmers’ markets and pay a premium for organic foods must be morons. This would be merely galling if Peterson were just some agribiz flunky. Coming from the head of the House ag committee, though, it’s appalling. Here’s the guy who has the power to rewrite our agricultural policies to encourage more sustainable farming practices, healthier school lunches, revitalized rural communities, better land stewardship—you know, all that crunchy granola stuff that forms the mainstay of the liberal elite diet—and he turns out to be, well, an agribiz flunky. Peterson’s really steamed that we urban types even have the temerity to take an interest in the agricultural policies that our tax dollars pay for. Back in September, Peterson told the San Francisco Chronicle: "Us guys in farm country, we don't know a thing about the big cities and we're not about to tell them what to do…and these big city editorial writers and others don't have a clue about what's going on in agriculture, and they ought to keep out of our business."
Actually, Congressman Peterson, it’s our business, and when it comes to what’s going on in agriculture, we apparently know more than you do, because you claim total ignorance of the many reasons why consumers are increasingly opting to go organic. You could get up to speed pretty quickly by reading Michael Pollan’s The Omnivore’s Dilemma—just out in paperback!—but I guess a “big city” professor of journalism (even worse, a west coast big city—Berkeley!) couldn’t possibly have anything to say that would be relevant to a rural regular Joe like yourself. Well, OK, then, how about borrowing a copy of Barbara Kingsolver’s Animal, Vegetable, Miracle from your local library? Kingsolver’s book offers a terrific crash course in this whole “eat local” phenomenon by which you profess to be baffled. But then you strike me as the kinda politician who, like our latest presidential candidate, Stephen Colbert, doesn’t really like books (unless they’re by him.) Maybe you’re more of a movie guy? If that’s the case, I can recommend a really great documentary about American agriculture. It’s called “King Corn,” and it opens in that big city where you sometimes work, DC, tomorrow night. Check it out! King Corn will give you a much better grasp of how our misguided agricultural policies are feeding the obesity epidemic and polluting our air, land and water. Haven’t got the time to sit through an 88-minute movie about industrial agriculture? No problem. You can learn about the dark side of factory farming from a fun little animated short called The Meatrix. I know that you find our big city ways strange and foreign, but we urban types do have one thing in common with you simple country folks—we all eat. It’s just that some of us don’t want to eat produce that’s permeated with pesticides, and meats from CAFOs that require more and more manure lagoons, subsidized by our tax dollars. We want clean food, clean air, and clean water. What’s dumb about that?
|
Chapter leaders...
Please login here.
Navigation |
If I am a Dumb Organic Consumer, Ignorance is Bliss
I guess I am dumb by Peterson's standards since I eat almost nothing that isn't organic. I guess it is smart, by those standards, to eat nutritionally depleted factory-farmed foods, genetically engineered foods with unknown health risks, and of course foods grown by people who make political contributions to the right people.
Personally, given these definitions I would rather stay dumb. I foolishly take comfort from knowing that the food I eat isn't contaminated by anything like e coli, pesticide, or questionable man-made strands of DNA. I enjoy the fact that it is cheaper for me to eat these so-called "expensive" organic foods because my food is 80% to 300% more nutritionally dense that the commercially grown foods, so at least twice as cost effective (see http://www.rawfoodlife.com/Articles___Research/Organic_vs_commercial_foo...)
Finally, I enjoy knowing that the lifestyle I choose to live is healthier, more enjoyable, tastes better, creates less garbage is sustainable and requires less energy. So I am a dumb person. Well, this is proof that the old saying IS true: "Ignorance Is Bliss!”
- RawFoodGuy
eating may be political, but it shouldn't be polarizing
I have to take exception to the implication you make on this site that only enlightened blue-state liberals are virtuous enough to care about where their food comes from. Democrats and Republicans alike are larding the Farm Bill full of provisions for agribusiness, and how well farmers and ranchers care for their land has little to do with their political views.
Aren't we all so quaint?
Go Kat! Excellent post.
send this to Senator Peterson!
Just as The Daily Show repeats ad infinitum, our government representatives are just plain IDIOTS! I hope you sent this post to him. What does it take to wake these people up?