Beverage & Dairy Industry Shills: Must We Swallow Their Swill?

Now that the majority of Americans are overweight if not downright obese, there’s a whole lotta hand wringin’ and head scratchin’ goin’ on. Who’s to blame? What can we do about it? How can we lead a healthier life?

The answers seem painfully obvious: don’t eat so much, and get more exercise. Is that so hard? Sadly, for many of us, the answer is yes, because gluttony and inertia are now the cultural norm in the U.S. Our consumer-driven economy counts on us to not do the math on that Angus Third Pounder or Mocha Frappuccino Venti. Although, if the “diabesity” epidemic continues unabated, it’s hard to see how our carb-and-carbon-crazed way of life won’t collapse under the weight of all that disease and disability.

Sure, we get some exercise; we exercise our freedom of choice to buy such free market marvels of American ingenuity as the Burger King Stacker (”choose from double, triple or quadruple layers of meat and cheese—topped with bacon and sauce…no veggies allowed”!) or Jimmy Dean Chocolate Chip Pancakes and Sausage on a Stick, which prompted Jon Stewart to exclaim, “Finally, the classic taste of chocolate chip pancake-wrapped sausage with the convenience of a stick!”

But we don’t have a choice in making the policies that underwrite the overproduction of the foods that are making us fat, because our government’s a wholly owned subsidiary of Big Food and Agribiz, who get the final say-so on our food and agriculture policies.

Consider the case of soda; now that it’s getting expelled from schools for getting an “F” in nutrition, the beverage industry’s scrambling to fill those vending machine slots with “healthy” fruit-based beverages.

How this will make a dent in the childhood obesity epidemic is a mystery, because fruit juice has about the same number of calories as soda does. Nonetheless, our acting Surgeon General, Dr. Stephen Galson, appeared on CNN’s House Calls With Dr. Sanjay Gupta this weekend and applauded the beverage industry’s efforts to baste our little butterballs with something other than soda.

Gupta asked Galson how the Department of Health and Human Services planned to combat the childhood obesity crisis:

GUPTA: … should the government hold individuals responsible if they don't exercise, if they have poor BMI, if they make poor dietary choices? Is there -- should there be almost a nanny state when it comes to this important issue?

GALSON: I don't think a nanny state is necessary, of course. Everybody has responsibilities for this. Should teachers be responsible? Yes. Should parents be responsible? Yes. Everywhere children touch, there should be an adult who knows about childhood obesity, knows how to prevent it, knows what to do, how to educate kids, how to feed them. This is a national global responsibility for every single person who touches children in this country from doctors, to nurses, to teachers. Everyone has a role.

Everyone, it seems, except the food industry and the more than $10 billion dollars it spends annually targeting kids. I’d call that a starring role, but it doesn’t merit a mention from Galson.

GUPTA: But let me go through some specific actions that are either in place or have been proposed and see what your thoughts are on them. A fat tax?

GALSON: I really don't know whether it would help. What I've heard about an example like that is some of the beverage industry is getting involved in trying to get some of these sweetened beverages out of school vending machines and substituting for them beverages that are more healthy. That is something that we think really works.

Yeah, replacing high-fructose-corn-syrup-sweetened soda with sugary fruit juices is huge. Because, you know, they’re natural. Naturally sugary. This really works, if by “works,” you mean saves the beverage industry from having to relinquish its ultra lucrative stake in school vending machines.

Gupta noted that Galson’s predecessor, Dr. Richard Carmona, testified that he’d been subjected to significant political interference in his four years as Surgeon General (among other things, Carmona was ordered to mention President Bush three times on every page of his speeches while being forbidden to address such issues as global warming, stem cells, or sex education.) Gupta asked Galson whether he’d had a similar experience:

GALSON: I haven't felt shackled at all. This has not been an issue for me. I have had total buy in to say whatever I think is important. And I've talked about childhood obesity since the second that I walked in the door. And I feel like I can say whatever I think is needed for the American public to move forward on this. So no problem for me.

But shills like Galson are a problem for us, and our government’s got plenty of ‘em. As OrangeClouds115, aka Jill Richardson, noted on Daily Kos yesterday, Pennsylvania’s about to ban the use of milk carton labels that tell you whether that milk comes from cows treated with rBGH, the Monsanto-made growth hormone.

You can argue about whether use of this hormone is healthy for cows or humans (there are indications that it’s not good for us, and solid evidence that it’s bad for the cows). What’s undisputed is: (a) consumers want to know whether the milk they’re buying comes from dairy producers who use this stuff, or not, and (b) they’ll gladly pay a premium for rBGH-free dairy products.

This is hurting Monsanto and the dairy farmers who use rBGH. So Dennis Wolff, Pennsylvania’s Secretary of Ag and a former dairy farmer himself, began pushing for the ban a while ago in response to a supposed public outcry from “confused consumers,” as a dairy diary from another Kossack, shirah, spelled out last Friday.

Of course, the real impetus for the campaign comes from Monsanto, who’s spending a fortune to prop up its product in the wake of massive consumer rejection. If Monsanto succeeds in depriving consumers of the right to choose rBGH-free dairy products in Pennsylvania, it will surely try the same thing in your state, too.

So, please, take a moment to write, call or e-mail Pennsylvania Governor Ed Rendell and ask that the ban—which is set to take effect on February 1st--be stopped (thanks to OrangeClouds115 for providing the info):

Email Governor Edward Rendell

Or, for maximum impact, write a letter:

Governor Edward G. Rendell's Office
225 Main Capitol Building
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17120

Or, make a phone call to the Governor's Office:
(717) 787-2500.

Dr. Sanjay Gupta is the

Dr. Sanjay Gupta is the chief medical correspondent for CNN, where he weighs in on broadcasts, and also runs a couple of blogs on CNN's Health site. Dr. Gupta has authored groundbreaking research, ran a successful practice as a neurosurgeon, and he did his undergraduate degree and his MD at University of Michigan, amongst the top in professional and graduate schools in the nation. Those programs aren't cheap – even with payday loans you can't afford it. He also worked as a White House Fellow during the Clinton administration. On assignment with CNN in Iraq, he participated in surgery to deal with damage done to US servicemen and Iraqi civilians. This all adds up to why Barack Obama has approached him to be the next Surgeon General of the United States, a position usually given to top medical authorities, which Dr. Gupta certainly appears to be. To see just how he operates click payday loans if you've got Dr. Gupta on the brain.

Holy cow!, I was looking for

Holy cow!, I was looking for industry shill examples for my advocacy against teen drinking and found your site. I asked the SG a question that stumped him...write me for a link...I am being incognito at the moment trying (against all my common sense) to go through the chain of cammand to get my questions answered...withour insulting these dippics...lol

Thanks

childhood obesity

I used to be a teacher. This issue seems pretty simple, and one we don't need to allocate millions of dollars of other people's money for. Mandatory recess or PE twice a day through grade 6, with no vending machines in the school. Mandatory daily lifetime conditioning classes in middle and high school to teach kids to take charge of their own health, with choice in the cafeteria between real cooked food and healthy deli, not junk. Let those motherly cafeteria ladies use ingredients they want to use to cook from scratch instead of the deep-fried, off the truck fare often mandated by our school boards (endless pizza, chicken nuggets, and burgers, anyone? I brought my lunch every day). On the few days they actually got to cook, they were really happy to serve the kids real food. No new bureaucracy necessary, no creation of "shills" for one political view or another. Just let the "motherly" types who take those self-sacrificing, low-wage jobs feeding our kids DO THEIR JOBS! And get the PE coaches educated to really do theirs, in cooperation with the other teachers of the school, to teach the kids that real health is their own responsibility. And thinking is not optional.